National Citizens Coalition Blog

Back to Main listings


Kudos to British Columbia Energy Minister Blair Lekstrom for putting taxpayers first!

It is not all that often that we see a politician who has a high profile cabinet post in a majority government do the right thing and stand up for his constiuents. Such is the case in this regard and you can read some background on this here.

Blair Lekstrom is one of those rare politicians, and he deserves hearty congratulations for standing up for his constituents whom he feels have been lied to about the HST. As an organization, we are very critical of elected politicians who do not represent their constituents’ wishes and spend taxpayers’ money as if it was their own. In this case, Blair Lekstrom did a very principled thing in resigning, and has shown some true leadership and character, both of which say a great deal about him as a person.

He is right in arguing that there was no public consultation on the HST. He is also very right in saying that British Columbians will need to have an open conversation about how services are provided and the need for program cuts or tax increases to balance the budget. What people are increasingly getting tired of across this country are elitist politicians with no regard for the citizens that elected them. I believe Blair Lekstrom has taken a  step in the right direction, and his peers would be wise to take note.

In regards to Premier Gordon Campbell, enjoy your time as Premier because I do believe that your days are numbered. British Columbians are not going to forget this when the next election rolls around. Things are going to get very interesting in British Columbia before this is over - there are now more anti-HST petition signatures than Liberal votes in many key ridings.

As usual, your comments are both welcome and appreciated.


Comments

Renato F. Vicente says:

I hope the same thing happened here in Ontario. We have a premier who lied and lied and yet many Ontarians believe him. He’s just catering to ethnic votes, but with the real voters who is familiar with this premier, he is bound to lose. I am a Conservative but the leader of the Conservative Party (Provincial)is quiet about all the issues which could be another disaster like John Tory. They fought for one issue only: funding for separate school and not touching the real issues. I hope its not the case.

submitted on June 16th, 2010 at 1:34 pm

Fred Zeitler says:

While I agree, timing of the HST is bad, its another tax and thats bad, the Liberal gov’t lied thats bad, Kudo’s to Blair Lekstrom that was good.

Having said all that, I personally am quite comfortable with an HST system. I’m pissed that the Federal Gov’t didn’t just man up and force all the Provinces to convert, eliminate all PST/GST forever and simply set an 8% HST country wide. I know I know makes too much sense.

Finally, its fine and well to slash and burn the Liberals, all it does is play into NDP hands, now there’s an option!! Yikes

submitted on June 16th, 2010 at 1:53 pm

LIZ says:

I also feel the liberals will pay the price at the poles and especially McGuinty. I was shocked when he was elected for the second time after the failed promises and lies. When is the tax upon tax going to stop, how our young people going to get ahead?

submitted on June 16th, 2010 at 2:08 pm

Dick Loewen says:

Here in Ontario we were taken on the Health Premium tax/premium which the Premier said would never happen.On the HST the Premier says that the manufactuers/businessess will reduce their prices which will offset the HST….yeah right..we’ll never see that.

As mentioned earlier the Conservative party in Ontario has been quiet on the HST issue and I don’t believe any party..Conservatives included… will campaign to reverst the HST. Too much money involved for the government and once the cash cow starts…no one will have the nerve to reverse it.

It’s a done deal….and unless the Conservatives in Ontario develop a platform that appeals to voters,Premier McGinty will be re-elected. It’s amazing that the electorate just doesn’t punish politicians for the the things they do and the promises they break. Maybe no one really gives a damn one way or the other. .

submitted on June 16th, 2010 at 2:10 pm

Paul Dekker says:

One unified tax makes way more sense than two seperate and differently applied taxes. The problem is the rate; the combined rate should have droped 1%. I don’t disagree that politicians in general are not representing the people of this country but I'’m not sure this is where the battle needs to be waged. Let’s focus on their wastefull spending. Let’s do away with votes of confidence so that minority governments can function. Let’s do away with the party system in general so that government can use the best people in the best jobs and stop wasting our money on pointless elections. Let’s put freedom back into our priorities as a nation.

submitted on June 16th, 2010 at 2:22 pm

Roger Marsh says:

A guy I worked with always votes for the incumbent. His reasoning?
The guy already in office has decorated his office and spent a bunch of bucks getting things the way he likes them. A new guy will start over and spend a bunch more public money to get things the way HE wants them.

I like to get the best guy in and punish weasels, but it’s like shooting yourself in the foot!

submitted on June 16th, 2010 at 2:38 pm

Judith Caldwell says:

HI Peter:

Just so you know I do read your emails & of course as mentioned before I’m very against the HST but what can one do other than constantly complain…only you seem to listen!!! So this week I’m prepaying my funeral & anything else that will avoid giving McGuinty that tax grab!!!
Judith Caldwell

submitted on June 16th, 2010 at 2:44 pm

Allan Johnson says:

I also want to extend Kudos to Blair Lekstrom. I commend him, I congratulate him and I admire him for taking a common sense stand on the very controversial HST issue.

I am sure his constituents also appreciate his values and character even more than ever. He has taken a more difficult path, and may be ridiculed by his fellow Liberal MLA’s for stepping out of alignment with the Premier. But, I have to think that there must a good many MLA’s who share the same postition as Blair Lekstrom, but are too afraid of the repurcussions to stand up for themselves and their constituents.

submitted on June 16th, 2010 at 3:40 pm

Ron says:

It really bugs me that the guy like Blair, who stood up for his constituents, like all our MLAs and MPs are suposed to– then reasigns. It may be the ‘honorable’ thing to do-I would rather see him stay in Govt. and continue fighting for what he believes is the right thing to do. Who knows-he might???have a little influence on some of the other guys that didn’t have the intestinal fortitude to do ‘the right thing’!
Whoever thinks the taxes should be combined has got ‘rock in his head’! When they put the GST(grab&steal tax) in, it was only going to be for 5 years to pay off the defficit. That was as much of a joke as when the Liberals were going to REMOVE it when elected. Then come right out and say–after being elected–”oh, we can’t afford to do away with it”! Then they raised it!—Ron

submitted on June 16th, 2010 at 5:00 pm

Gord Drimmie says:

It’s a bad tax period. Reducing it 1% overall is not the answer. When you tax the necessities of life an extra 8% (gasoline; internet; electricity; water; heating gas/fuel), it’s just not right.

Watch the underground economy boom.

Neither the PC’s or the NDP have the guts to repeal it….althought it ought to be repealed. There are other ways to balance the books…..but nobody cares. Nobody….

submitted on June 16th, 2010 at 5:04 pm

Henry van der Molen says:

I would be worried that the alternative here in BC might be the NDP party, but I don’t have to be, we have a fledgling Conservative Party that needs to make itself known. Yes there is a Conservative Party, I believe they have a website, check them out.

submitted on June 16th, 2010 at 6:09 pm

Cam Walker says:

The various ethnic groups in Ontario neither understand the tax issue nor want to. They simply vote the way they immigrated, i.e. Liberal, which is the way their bread is buttered. It will be so forever and the Liberals-damn them-know it!

submitted on June 16th, 2010 at 6:15 pm

Bob Sleeth says:

I believe the HST is the right way to go. Reduce income taxes. Consumption taxes just make more sense.

submitted on June 16th, 2010 at 6:18 pm

Dick Tafel says:

My book - YOU Can Control Your Government - describes the details about Direct Democracy - or the manner of forcing a referendum if sufficient numbers sign a petition demanding such - upon issues -before they can become law. Such Referendums are available, in Canadian provinces, only in B.C. at the moment.
Even there the obstacles placed in the way within the legislation are extremely formidable. Only with a very hot issue, with an experienced, clever publicist, like former premier Vanderdam (sp?) could one likely force such a matter, even in B.C. There ten% of the citizens in every riding must sign such petition for it to become required to have a vote upon it.
But, why should not the rest of the country be required to have such possible referendums: - as in Switzerland, and 24 of the US. States?
B.C. is clearly showing the way in modernizing our vaunted, but ineffective democracy.

submitted on June 16th, 2010 at 6:57 pm

Larry McNary says:

Kudos to Lekstrom. Hope other MLA’s join him. Gordon Campbell believes the HST is great for B.C. and he will not budge on his position even though the voters do not want more taxation at this time. I know the economists of this country think the HST is the way to go, and under differnt circumstances and times they could be right.

The way I see it is the CEO’s of business and their VP’s etc. really like the idea of reduced taxation as their bottom line will greatly improve. Good for them as the next step is nice fat bonus. When a CEO takes home $10,000,000.00 per year (Goldcorp) and more the discrepancy in wages and spendable income are becoming a real problem in Canada. Campbells comments are that business wil reduce costs and therefor pass savings on to the consumer. However the B.C. Liquor board recentltly announced an increase in the cost of liquor by 2% and will not be passing on supposed HST savings. No wonder folks can’t put money away for retirement and now the Government wants to step in and charge an additional tax for CPP. When does it end.

I have been a conservative all my life and don’t expect to change as I truly believe business has to thrive and prosper, but so does the common man. Somehow we need leaders who understand that money can’t be used just for the wealthy and let everyone else suffer.

When Gordon Campbell was first elected he froze wages for all Prov. employees except for the high level managers (first mistake). He then proceeded to give all the MLA’s a raise and if that wasn’t enough he instituted a rich pension scheme (six years in office and they are eligible). Next he gave CNR a lovely contract for B.C. Rail. Next he introduces a carbon tax, as if we aren’t already paying through the nose for fuel here in B.C. Next he builds a great highway to Whistler because of the Olympics and while I agree a better highway was needed, perhaps now is not the time. Oh and I don’t want to forget another 1/2 billion to cover a sports stadium. Oh yeah and expand gambling in B.C. Now the HST. Gordon Campbell will not ever get my vote again as he has in the past.

submitted on June 16th, 2010 at 7:17 pm

Don says:

To bad the the rest of our MLA’s wouldn’t speek for their voter’s and give our premier a message to wake up.

submitted on June 16th, 2010 at 10:45 pm

norm lorenz says:

Time will tell whether he is noble or manipulative as Jay Hill is not running again and there are rumors Lekstrom may seek that federal seat. If that is his intention then it is crass political posturing. If he runs again provincially as an independant then I will extend respect.

submitted on June 17th, 2010 at 12:49 am

George McCutcheon says:

When Campbell was in opposition he proposed a fundaqmental change in the way elections should operate. Frankly, I agreed with him. We got a chance once campbell got a majority government. We got a chance to vote on campbells proposed change on how many partys could work together to truly represent the voteing public. We needed(I believe) 60% to pass a rule change. I believe we got about 56% and lost. (poor education for voters). Mr campbell later in his political career decided to give the voteing public a second chance at election reform. Again, there was no meaning full education on the proposed reform and there were many mis-information commercials on TV. I wonder just who paid for those adds. Again we lost our voice and achieve only samall percentage of the required vote. I think POLITICS stinks and it smrlls like a Campbell wind has been blowing in BC. When we believe these politicos we get what we vote for. Isn’t politics Wonderful.
The current HST “THING” was just dishonest. But then aqain, we, got just what we asked for. Lies and verry complicated sales of our assets, (railroad, bridges, surplus ships, and probably much more. It will take a forensic audit to determin which politican should spend some time in JAIL!

submitted on June 17th, 2010 at 4:23 am

R. Max Wideman says:

If we have to have both taxes, then in principle, combining them is the right thing to do. It reduces the amount of administration and paperwork, meaning less government - for which the NCC campaigns. However, the downside is that it also hides accountability away from those who have some control over it (i.e. at least the PST part). British Columbians and Ontarians should look for a corresponding reduction in bureaucrats!

submitted on June 17th, 2010 at 10:31 am

martha says:

It has always been said Governments don’t tell the truth. I remember when the GST was introduced. How we all hated it. Mr. Chretien pointed to his Red Book told us if we voted for him he would get rid of the GST. We still have the GST. Thanks to Mr. Harper he did reduce it to 5%.

submitted on June 17th, 2010 at 11:16 am

Terry says:

The whole tax issue is about how the Government manages cost.Usually companies do things in house or contract the work out, however it is do the cheapest way possible. Job security in a union contract! No I disagree. Your job security should be yourself. You go to work and do your best. That is your job security.We need to overhaul our basic education system and put some reality related curriculum such as the pros and cons of capitalism and socialism. The HST tax will be implimented and raised more often then lowered to reflect Government spending.What I would like to see is interest rates put on a market basis of supply and demand rather then have Government in debt,competing with the private banks and using inerest rates like an accelerator pedal on an automabile. Speed up the economy with low interest rates only to raise them again to slow down inflation. The poor average home owner is suffering from D.I.S. deficiency in stability. This leads to a whole arena of DIS from disable to disunion in the dictionary. In other words NEGATIVE ENERGY ON THE MIND AND BODY.

submitted on June 17th, 2010 at 11:39 am

Keith says:

I personally would not mind paying taxes if I felt that I was getting my money’s worth but, being from Nova Scotia and seeing what has gone on with the abuse of taxpayer money by our provincial politicians, seeing our Premier Darrel Dexter break his election promise not to raise taxes and trying to justify doing so by stating that he did not know how bad the situation was (and hearing ex NDP Ontario Premier Bob Rae state that Dexter would have known) I have become skepticle of all politicians. (This is just one example among many that has made me believe that we Canadians are not being given good government)

It is very refreshing to hear that there is one MPP who is standing up for the wishes of his constituents which is very rare in provincial and federal politics where MPs and MPPs are expected to be puppets and tow the party line.

submitted on June 17th, 2010 at 1:10 pm

Ilona says:

Too bad there are not more politicians like him
Great job

submitted on June 17th, 2010 at 2:36 pm

Hugh Campbell says:

I think people are forgetting the power of the vote. The vote is the best alternative to war as I hope you remember when swords and clubs were used before a voting system of government was instituted. The trouble is people do not vote enough. Everyone should voluntarily vote!!!! Always!!! Disillusioned voters say, ” but there is no one to vote for, they are all doing something stupid!” That is sometimes true such as in B.C. right now where the N.D.P. are worse than the Liberals and that is why the N.D.P. lost big time a few elections ago as they pushed their socialist ideology over the top of practical solutions. Vote anyway!! If the carbon tax based on false science bugs you or the HST or whatever then choose that topic and go and write across your ballot, ” no HST”. That spoiled ballot and it’s reason will be noted. Every party sends scrutineers to make sure that every vote they can get is counted with no bullfudging from the opposition. If the 25 to 65 percent [or even 1, 2 or 3 percent ] of people who do not go to the poles did that you can be sure the candidates would take note of the issues that were costing them thousands of votes from people that actually turned out to vote. Ridings are often won or lost by a small number of votes, under 50 votes, many times. So, make your voice heard where it counts and at the poles is that ultimate place; that is where power changes hands. I am telling you, vote or get what you deserve! [Uhh—if everyone votes the wrong way you will still get what you deserve but at least you asked for it and you might get a chance to change course in your direction the next time.]

submitted on June 17th, 2010 at 3:40 pm

Tony Lloyd says:

I live in BC and closely observed the last provincial election. To state that Gordon Campbell or the BC Liberals lied regarding HST is a complete fabrication. Also combining our Provincial Sales Tax and the Federal GST into one single tax with one collection agency is an excellent move which will be very beneficial for the province in terms of becoming more competitive and creating more jobs.
I am very disappointed with the Coalition taking such a stupid position on the issue. I have been a supporter for many years and am completly in favor of cutting waste.Nobody likes taxes but the money to pay for all our benefits has to come from somewhere and anyone who studies the issue objectively will agree that consumption taxes as a source of revenue are more efficient than income taxes.
This issue is not a matter of cutting waste but rather a matter of improving the tax system. Why don’t you stick to worrying about waste?

submitted on June 17th, 2010 at 5:18 pm

Leave a Comment