National Citizens Coalition Blog

Back to Main listings


Time to treat taxpayers with respect!

The peace and quiet from a federal political perspective was broken with a bang on October 16th when the Throne Speech was presented to Canada. The speech was a very clever political document outlining the Conservative agenda for the upcoming fall session of parliament.

 

The decision to have the speech read by the Governor General in prime time was a welcomed one that gave many Canadians the opportunity to understand what the Conservative agenda for Canada is. To quote others” it is not a scary right wing agenda”

 

The Throne Speech pointed in a direction far different from the political shenanigans that were witnessed during the last session in the House of Commons. The actions of our federal representatives in the House and in committee, where individual pieces of legislation were debated and analyzed, was nothing short of an embarrassment for all political parties. If our children behaved in this manner they would be getting a “time out” and sitting in the corner to reflect on their bad behavior. We can only hope that this session of parliament will be more productive.

 

The fact that the last session of parliament got so little done was a major reason why the Conservatives laid out their desired policies in the Throne speech for all to hear. What Prime Minister Harper has said is, “here is our agenda and if you support the Throne Speech than you will have to support the legislation.”  For the opposition parties, this brings up some interesting opportunities and challenges because there is wide disagreement over many of the specific policy pieces contained in the Throne Speech.

 

The Conservative proposal to talk about income tax cuts will be welcome relief to the millions of overburdened taxpayer that continue to struggle to make ends meet. With the federal coffers overflowing with a $14.2 billion surplus, these proposed tax cuts reflect a responsible and accountable policy position. The fact that this surplus was applied to pay down the government debt is a good thing, but it is now time to give some of that money back to the hard working citizens of this great country. We do not need “boutique” tax cuts like athletic club memberships deductions; we need across the board tax cuts that are aimed at the middle class who bear the burden of the ever increasing size of government.

 

One area in the Throne Speech that will involve a great deal of dialogue will be the Conservative proposal to limit the federal government’s role in provincial jurisdictions like health care and education. Many Canadians would believe that these are areas of federal jurisdiction, because for many years the Liberals used their federal power to overrun provincial jurisdictions in order to remain in power. The Liberal party recognized that creating the false perception of looking after and taking care of Canadians was what it would take to continue being reelected.  Paul Martin’s $42 billion “fix for a generation” health care plan was one of those big government decisions that realistically was not a fix for our bloated and unsustanable health care system.

 

The Conservatives would like to get out of provincial jurisdictions and have the decisions about the delivery health care and education made by provincial governments.  The Provinces are much closer to the “client” – yes that is us as taxpayers – and are better suited to make these decisions. This will be an interesting battle and one that the Liberals and NDP will certainly oppose.

 

The National Citizens Coalition would welcome any government action that recognizes that there is only one taxpayer and that individual does not need provincial and federal duplication.  Duplication results in bloated government departments that do the same thing on a federal provincial and sometimes even municipal level. One thing is a certainty; this country is over governed.

 

One major disappointment in the Throne Speech was that there was no mention of health care and the significant problems that our health care system is operating on. It is a sad state of affairs when Canada’s once vaunted health care system now keeps company with  North Korea and Cuba as the only countries in the world who do not allow some form of private health care delivery as a backup to the public system. This is clearly not working in Canada as 3 million of us currently have no access to a family physician.

 

The National Citizens Coalition will continue to push all levels of government for more accountability; more efficient government and much needed tax relief. We also hope that there will be some honest debate on all of these issues with people from all across this great Country. If the recently completed Ontario election, with the total lack of any conversation about relevant issues, is any indication more work needs tobe done by all levels of government to actually start taking action on issues that really matter.


Comments

Jim Stewart says:

Amen to that!

submitted on October 24th, 2007 at 11:48 am

Doug Bissett says:

I disagree with the opinion that we should have a tax cut, based on the federal surplus. Every penny of the surplus should be going to pay down the debt, and no tax cuts should take place, until every penny has been paid off. After all, those who benefited from the majority of the borrowing, will not be around all that much longer, and it is totally unfair to leave the job of paying off the debt, to those who had no part in creating it, and have had no benefit from it. Some may argue, that all have benefited from the debt, but that is simply smoke, and mirrors. All of us have suffered from the debt, and we will continue to suffer from it, until it is paid off.

submitted on October 24th, 2007 at 12:00 pm

DStone says:

Federal Tax Cuts will mean very little if the Provinces don’t co-operate! In the past provincial governments have raised taxes when the Federal government has attempted to reduce them and vice versa. Who can forget when Mike Harris in Ontario lowered taxes & the federal liberals proceeded to raise their taxes accordingly?

If the Harper government were to lower income taxes who would doubt for a second, that the McGinty Liberals, flush from a recent 4 year majority mandate, won’t raise their taxes. This would effectively turn the tax cutting gesture into an additional federal to provincial transfer & the tax payer won’t see a thing!

submitted on October 24th, 2007 at 12:26 pm

Paul Dekker says:

And then to add insult to injury, Mr Fahrety points a finger at the retail sector for not lowering prices in light of the US dollar parity. Is anything still manufactured in the US? I think the various levels of government have more room to lower retail prices than the retail sector. Who do they think pays for all their excess anyway?

submitted on October 24th, 2007 at 12:30 pm

Anonymous says:

we need income tax cuts not gst reductions

submitted on October 24th, 2007 at 1:43 pm

L.C.icholls says:

I agree that most taxpayers need some cuts. I also agree that the darn debt should be paid. Couldn’t we manage to put at least half against the debt and cut the taxes (preferrably against corporations so that we don’t lose more jobs due to taxes).
I do not have any connection with corporations but I feel we have lost a lot of investment in Canada because of our high taxes.

submitted on October 24th, 2007 at 7:18 pm

David Bawden says:

NCC didn’t comment on the proposed reduction in the GST, a move that may have popular appeal, but is the very antithesis of what the government should be doing. Why the reticence?

submitted on October 25th, 2007 at 12:13 pm

GWarner says:

I noted in today’s paper Finance Minister Flaherty exhorting business to lower their prices so Canadians can buy goods in Canada at the same price as they can in the USA. He conveniently chose to forget that the much maligned ‘greedy’ Canadian businessman has to pay most of his income to Mr. Flaherty. The good Finance Minister could fix things quickly by seriously lowering taxes in Canada.

submitted on October 25th, 2007 at 10:52 pm

Anonymous says:

Comparing my household (DINKs , household income north of $200K) and my in-laws (1 1/2 incomes, 2 kids, household income south of $100K) and our respective taxes, spending etc., I have to say that a GST reduction would benefit them a lot more than us, and a lot more than an income tax reduction.

submitted on October 30th, 2007 at 3:39 pm

m wiebe says:

Cannot understand the opposition and the media. The GST benifits everyone even those who don’t pay taxes. The NDP is always saying there is nothing for the poor, and yet they don’t see the advantage - how blind.
But the Harper Government is doing what he said he would do and that is so different from the previous Government. I’m happy with the tax cuts.

submitted on October 30th, 2007 at 10:58 pm

Leave a Comment